background

Gamer Crit

Sonic Classic Collection Review: Nostalgia, But Flawed

Sonic Classic Collection Review: Nostalgia, But Flawed
Review

Sonic Classic Collection Review: Nostalgia, But Flawed
Review

Sonic Classic Collection


Release Date:Mar 2010
IGDB Rating:6.0/10
Published:6 months ago
7/10
Remarkable
Sonic Classic Collection is a compilation of the classic Sonic the Hedgehog games, including Sonic the Hedgehog, Sonic the Hedgehog 2, Sonic the Hedgehog 3, and Sonic & Knuckles. As a longtime fan of the franchise, I was excited to dive back into these iconic games and relive the nostalgia of my childhood.

The collection offers the convenience of having these beloved games all in one place, making it easy to jump between titles without having to swap out cartridges or consoles. The graphics have been updated to fit the capabilities of the Nintendo DS, but the core gameplay remains faithful to the original titles.
Sonic Classic Collection screenshot 1

Playing through Sonic Classic Collection, it was a joy to revisit the fast-paced platforming action that made these games so popular. The levels are well-designed, with a good mix of speed and platforming challenges. Sonic's iconic speed is just as thrilling as I remembered, and the power-ups and collectibles add an extra layer of excitement.

However, despite the nostalgia and solid gameplay, Sonic Classic Collection falls short in a few areas. One major issue is the controls. The Nintendo DS's D-pad is not the most comfortable for precise movements, and this becomes especially frustrating during the more challenging sections of the game. It often feels like the controls are working against you, leading to unnecessary deaths and frustration.
Sonic Classic Collection screenshot 2

Another disappointment is the lack of additional features or enhancements. While the games themselves are great, there is little else to offer in terms of bonus content. It would have been nice to see some behind-the-scenes material or developer interviews to further enhance the nostalgic experience.

Additionally, the absence of online multiplayer is a missed opportunity. Sonic games are known for their multiplayer modes, and it's a shame that this collection doesn't allow for multiplayer gaming. It would have been a great way to compete with friends or even strangers online.
Sonic Classic Collection screenshot 3

Overall, Sonic Classic Collection provides a solid dose of nostalgia and a chance to relive the iconic Sonic games. The updated graphics and convenience of having them all in one place are definite positives. However, the frustrating controls, lack of additional features, and absence of online multiplayer prevent it from being a truly exceptional collection. Fans of the franchise will still find enjoyment in revisiting these classics, but they may be left wanting more.
Article tags:
Sonic Classic Collection
Sonic the Hedgehog
platformer
nostalgia
Nintendo DS