background

Gamer Crit

Artifact Review: A Promising Concept Hindered by Poor Execution

Artifact Review: A Promising Concept Hindered by Poor Execution
Review

Artifact Review: A Promising Concept Hindered by Poor Execution
Review

Artifact


Release Date:Nov 2018
IGDB Rating:8.3/10
Published:7 months ago
4.5/10
Meh-tastic
Artifact, developed by Valve Corporation, is a digital collectible card game (CCG) that had a lot of potential on paper. With the pedigree of Valve behind it, many players had high hopes for the game. However, upon release, it became clear that Artifact failed to live up to expectations.

One of the biggest issues with Artifact is its complex and convoluted gameplay mechanics. While some players enjoy the challenge of mastering intricate systems, the learning curve in Artifact is steep and unforgiving. Newcomers to the genre or casual players may quickly become overwhelmed and frustrated.
Artifact screenshot 1

Another major drawback of Artifact is its monetization model. The game initially had a price tag and also implemented a system where players had to purchase packs of cards to build their decks. This resulted in a pay-to-win environment, as players who were willing to spend more money had a significant advantage over those who didn't. This monetization approach was met with heavy criticism and ultimately led to a decline in the player base.

Furthermore, the lack of meaningful progression and rewards in Artifact is disappointing. Unlike other successful CCGs, where players have a sense of progression and accomplishment, Artifact offers little incentive to keep playing. This lack of engagement can quickly lead to player burnout and a feeling that the game is simply a money-grabbing endeavor.
Artifact screenshot 2

Visually, Artifact does have a polished and aesthetically pleasing presentation. The card artwork is detailed, and the overall design is clean and professional. However, this alone cannot compensate for the game's fundamental flaws.

In terms of gameplay variety, Artifact does offer a range of different modes and formats. However, the core gameplay experience remains the same, and the limited card pool and unbalanced meta make the game feel repetitive and stale after a while.
Artifact screenshot 3

Overall, Artifact had the potential to be a standout digital card game. However, due to its complex mechanics, flawed monetization model, lack of meaningful progression, and repetitive gameplay, it falls short of its promise. Unless significant changes are made to address these issues, it is hard to recommend Artifact to players looking for a rewarding and enjoyable CCG experience.
Article tags:
Artifact
digital collectible card game
CCG
Valve
game review